Home Korea Japan China
STANDARDS WATCH > WNSRP

 


“As 3G multimedia devices continue to proliferate, it becomes even more crucial that all devices adhere to a standards-based architecture that promotes interoperability, mobility across all networks, and support of current and future services and standards,” said Daniel Longfield, Senior Wireless Analyst in Frost and Sullivan’s Mobile & Wireless group.  “The proposed WNSRP standard as just such an effort where, rather than being locked into a proprietary solution that every device in a network needs to support in order for any of them to function, the industry is promoting a standards-based approach that will be available to all 3G solution developers and equipment vendors.”

WNSRP Overview

WNSRP is a powerful new standard proposed by a consortium of 3G equipment solution providers and currently under consideration by the ITU. 

This proposed standard dramatically speeds the initiation of 3G-324M-based video sessions through the streamlining of the call set up signaling - necessary to establish the connection between two handsets and between a handset and a media server which might provide additional value-added services such as video streaming for entertainment or surveillance.

WNSRP has already been adopted by leading mobile operators and handset manufacturers and is actively promoted by these major industry players to the various standardization organizations. 

Top

How WNSRP Works

One of the remaining challenges for real-time 3G video services is set-up time.  Setting up a typical video session requires each end to send up to ten messages to the other terminal, each time waiting for a message to be received and acknowledged before sending the next one.  And, if a message is not received, the sending device must wait and finally “time out” before retransmitting.  The delay introduced in this process leads to long video call setup times that, while acceptable for early generations of video service, is very undesirable once 3G video (streaming and calling) becomes a mainstream service.

The WNSRP proposed standard is based on a powerful new approach to call signaling that eliminates the message queuing and “time out” issues inherent to the 3G-324M standard.  With WNSRP, all signaling is sent as a single batch to be processed by the receiving device.  Missed messages are immediately detected by the receiving device and retransmission requests are spontaneously generated.  This leads to extremely rapid call setup times, bringing video connectivity close to the same level of service as traditional telephony.

Top

Benefits of WNSRP over Proprietary Solutions

Unique features of the WNSRP standard over proprietary vendor-promoted solutions include:

  • Protocol independence - enabling support of fast connectivity with any other device, even if it is IP-based (e.g. IP video streaming server or a PC-based video terminal).
  • Non-proprietary architecture – open for any and all developers to implement.  Also, not all devices in a network needs to support the solution in order for the network and the devices to function.
  • Network independent - does not interact with underlying network protocols or codecs, enabling WNSRP-based devices to operate even when roaming in other mobile networks.
  • Future Proof – as WNSRP does not interact with the underlying call processing, there will be no conflict with future services, standards, or protocols that might later be added to the device.
  • Backwards compatibility: As WNSRP is a natural addition to the 3G-324M standard, implementing it will not require manufacturers to recall phones.

Top

Comparing WNSRP to Other Approaches

Issue Reducing Timeout Packing H.245 Messages Proprietary LAPM/V.42 WNSRP
NSRP requires the acknowledgement of a message before sending another message. No Partially No Yes Yes
Mobile connections are prone to error and NSRP does not retransmit a message until a timeout occurs. Yes No No No Yes
The average call setup scenario requires a large quantity of messages and an acknowledgment of each message before transmission of the next message. No No Yes Yes Yes

Top

Deeper Description of Benefits

3G Quick Connect Through New Processing of Existing Signaling
The delay in 3G-324M call setup time is caused by multiple H.245 message transmissions in several protocol layers, many of which require an acknowledgement before the transmission of the next message. A single round-trip of a message in a 3G-324M connection typically requires 800 milliseconds or more. Call setup typically requires transmitting ten H.245 messages to establish media transmission resulting in a setup time of up to eight seconds (not including the initial setup time of the 3G call connection itself). This is long even without taking into account errors on the network.

An additional contributing factor to call setup time is the acknowledgment required by SRP (Simple Retransmission Protocol) or NSRP (Numbered Simple Retransmission Protocol) frames. NSRP frames are used to send the H.245 messages. Each NSRP command frame can hold several H.245 messages. An NSRP command frame cannot be sent for an H.245 message before the previously sent NSRP command frame is acknowledged by an NSRP response frame. Sometimes H.245 messages are segmented on top of more than a single NSRP command frame by CCSRL (Control Channel Segmentation and Reassembly Layer).

WNSRP (Windowed NSRP) speeds up the handling of H.245 messages in H.324M by using a windowing mechanism that can send several different messages at the same time. It ensures that all messages are received and are in the correct order. WNSRP works in a similar manner to NSRP. It adds a response window that enables an overlap of the round trips required by H.245 messages, thus reducing call setup time.

The proposed WNSRP solution is a joint contribution of RADVISION and Motorola (with many other vendors committing to support) and is currently being considered by the ITU-T for approval.

Top

Fast Session Initiation With Non-3G Devices
Because WNSRP is protocol independent, it is not only ideal for point-to-point 3G video calls but is also unique in the market for its support of connectivity between 3G devices and devices running other signaling protocols such as IP.  WNSRP enables session establishment between 3G-324M devices with video telephony end points (H.323 and SIP), video streaming, video portal, and video mail IP servers, and other network devices.

Top

Future Proof
Unlike competing solutions, which are proprietary communications architectures that are part of a device’s underlying terminal, WNSRP simply provides a different way of handling existing standard signaling without interacting with the underlying codecs.  As such, WNSRP is not part of the underlying device functionality and is immune to future incompatibility issues that could arise through the additions of new codecs, new capabilities, and new call messages. 

Top

Network Independent Leads to Roaming and High Reliability
On a related issue, because WNSRP is not a new way of signaling but just a different way of processing existing signaling, it is network and MSC (switch) transparent – enabling 3G handsets to roam to countries and networks without interoperability issues.  Additionally, its overlay architecture makes it immune to network errors because it does not introduce new signaling that needs to be network validated but rather handles existing signaling in a new way.

Top